Alex McSkean put the Mikes 1-0 up in the 13' with an angled drive.
Tyrell Hamilton equalised in the 37', out strengthening Craven before firing home to make it 1-1
Harry Sweeney put Mikes back in front in the 61' drilling hard and low past Randle to make it 2-1.
Church equalised in the 2nd minute of added time when a cross found Waldron to head it to Willets who headed past Gwilliams to send the match into a penalty shoot-out, 2-2 after 90 mins.
With the scores 4-4 after West, Craven, Brown and Parry had converted for the Mikes and Abbey, Hamilton, Waldron and Spiers for the Church, Boldmere's 5th penalty was sent high and wide from Thompson-Brown to give debutant Josh Dugmore the chance to send Church through to the next round, which he made no mistake to send Church through 4-5 on penalties